Why We Can't Have Our Facts Back

Engaging Science, Technology, and Society

View Publication Info
Field Value
Title Why We Can't Have Our Facts Back
Creator Marres, Noortje
Subject STS; democratic theory; sociology of technology
demarcation; knowledge technology; knowledge democracy; digital society; public facts
Description How do we make the case for “knowledge democracy” in the face of the growing influence of right-wing figures and movements that denounce experts and expertise? While the threats to knowledge posed by these movements are real, it would be a mistake to return to a classic intellectual strategy––the politics of demarcation––in the face of this danger. Examining practical proposals for combatting fake news and opinion manipulation on the Internet, namely so-called "fact-checking" tools and services, I argue that they threaten to enroll us in a problematic normative project, one that aims to re-establish a hierarchy between knowledge and its presumed opposite, non-knowledge, or anti-knowledge. I list a number of shortcomings of this strategy. Most importantly, it distracts us from the role of technology in the crisis of public evidence in today's computationally-intensive societies. Social media are a truth-less public sphere by design. A politics of demarcation also puts us at risk of forgetting a key insight from the previous century that remains valid today: knowledge democracy is a re-constructive practice and an ideal. Instead of consolidating hierarchies of knowledge through facts that derive their authority form outside the public sphere, we need to recover the central role in public life of experimental facts: statements whose truth value is unstable. The experimental validation of public knowledge must happen in the public domain.  
Publisher The Society for Social Studies of Science
Date 2018-07-24
Type info:eu-repo/semantics/article
Peer-reviewed Article
experimentalist approaches to knowledge, technology and politics
Format application/pdf
Identifier https://estsjournal.org/index.php/ests/article/view/188
Source Engaging Science, Technology, and Society; Vol 4 (2018); 423-443
Language eng
Relation https://estsjournal.org/index.php/ests/article/view/188/162
Coverage US, UK, NL and other places where the anti-intellectual right has recently gained ground

Rights Copyright (c) 2018 Noortje Marres

Contact Us

The PKP Index is an initiative of the Public Knowledge Project.

For PKP Publishing Services please use the PKP|PS contact form.

For support with PKP software we encourage users to consult our wiki for documentation and search our support forums.

For any other correspondence feel free to contact us using the PKP contact form.

Find Us


Copyright © 2015-2018 Simon Fraser University Library